
The vilification of Russia will not serve us well if we want sustainable peace in Europe.
Historians like Geoff Roberts prefer the long view, looking at events from a distance, which helps them to be as dispassionate, as objective as possible. But sometimes history calls historians to comment when the smell of cordite is still in the air.
In terms of Russophobic propaganda, Roberts says, the last three years have been more toxic than anything he has seen. It has compelled him, he says, to eschew some of his scholarly habits – being an “archive rat” – and step into the ring. Read on.
Latest Articles
Professor Geoffrey Roberts is one of a growing number of ‘free thinkers’ who are rejecting the standard Western propaganda model that frames Putin and Russia as merchants of evil, instead ascribing to them motives that are both pragmatic and commonplace. This leaves plenty of room to criticize Putin’s regime and its hardball geopolitics. These academics, however, have shouldered the intellectual’s role to challenge the dominant narrative and expose underlying untruths – “Russia’s totally unprovoked war”, etc.
As any rookie strategist knows, outcome-focussed policy is based around the alignment of ends, ways and means: what you set as your goals must be matched with a clear strategy and the necessary resources to achieve them. Ukraine as a Western proxy war has proven a massive failure on all three counts.
The nuclear-free campaign, led by Wellington back in the 1980s, is a template worth reviving.
Wellington became the first city in New Zealand – and the first capital in the world – to declare itself nuclear free in 1982. It followed the excellent example of Missoula, Montana, USA, the first city in the world to do so, in 1978.
Romania’s ruling elites have just banned the leading candidate in the upcoming Presidential elections. Protesters chanted in Bucharest this week:“The last resort is another revolution”. People should sit up and pay attention: that sentiment echoes the 1989 overthrow of the dictator Nicolae Ceaușescu; it is a call of desperation and defiance a reminder of that era and the sacrifice Romanians made to drive the dictator from power – and to win the right to free and fair elections.
10 Downing Street has dismissed the claims as Russian disinformation but the clinical profiles seem accurate according to sources in Washington, Paris and London who spoke on condition of anonymity. Dr Freud has been uncontactable since the leaks. The Palais de l'Élysée has warned that the Tik-Tok “désinformation scandaleuse” is so serious that the next French Presidential elections may have to be postponed indefinitely in order to preserve democracy.
EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has called for the EU to turn Ukraine into a “steel porcupine” and for Europe to undertake a massive rearmament. If successful, the project would convert the EU from a largely political-economic union into a military-industrial superpower. It could also create a debt bomb as well as cluster bombs of social discontent that explode at various points in the future.
Witnessing the extraordinary cage fight this week between Zelensky and Trump in the Oval Office was an eye-popping glimpse into what is normally kept behind closed doors when world leaders meet to nut out matters of great consequence.
What we seem to be back to is the kind of unequal treaties
The Western media went into overdrive this past week to work the laconic Kiwis into a mild frenzy over three Chinese naval vessels conducting exercises in the Tasman Sea a few thousand kilometres off our shores. What was really behind this orchestrated campaign?
Lest we forget. On 25 February last year Aaron Bushnell, a 25 year-old active duty US serviceman, self-immolated in front of the Israeli Embassy in Washington. His last words on this Earth, as the fire consumed him, were: “Free Palestine!”
Earlier that day, Aaron posed on X what I am sure will become an historic question re-posed for generations to come:
Time will prove that an ugly peace delivers more than a beautiful war. Russia and the US are setting to work on something even bigger than the Ukraine conflict: normalising relations between the two superpowers which will have huge consequences economically, geopolitically and, hopefully, all to the benefit of the long-suffering Ukrainians and other peoples caught between the two behemoths.
The Government and the mainstream media have gone ballistic (thankfully not literally just yet) over the move by the small Pacific nation to sign a strategic partnership with China in Beijing this week. It is the latest in a string of island nations that have signalled a closer relationship with China, something that rattles nerves and sabres in Wellington and Canberra.
It generally ends badly. An old tyrant embarks on an ill-considered project that involves redrawing maps. They are heedless to wise counsel and indifferent to indigenous interests or experience. Before they fail, are killed, deposed or otherwise disposed of, these vicious old men can cause immense harm.
Alternative voices
Get a big, broader, more progressive perspective on what is happening in our world.
Two of Australia’s sharpest strategic thinkers tackle the great challenge facing Australia - and New Zealand.
Amb. Chas Freeman: Ukraine’s Final Hours? Israel’s Bold Move to Unite Shia & Sunni Shakes the World!
Ukraine's foreign minister visits Beijing for talks - the first trip by a government representative to China since Russia's invasion more than two years ago. Beijing is intensifying its diplomatic efforts.
The German crisis grows.
A united Asia. Pan-Asianism is bound to come back.
European irrationality in Ukraine - Michael von der Schulenburg, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen
UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese is a legal and moral advocate for humanity.
Kelley Vlahos, Editorial Director at Responsible Statecraft, moderates a panel on "American Prosperity" featuring Saagar Enjeti, David Goldman, and Jake Werner at Quincy Institute's Conference, "A Foreign Policy for the Middle Class."
China’s DONE With Canada As Desperate Punishments Begin, US Ban Backfires On Major G7 Industry